100k School Debt to Financial Freedom – Merch by Amazon Update 4

Once again I am a bit late on writing this case study so I would like to appologize. I just spend the weekend in Seattle attending the Merch by Amazon conference and eating a LOT of fresh seafood!

I guess that marks 2 months in a row that I was away at a conference but this was one particularly great. It was the first Merch by Amazon conference ever and I got to meet a ton of really great people in the community. Special shout outs to Lanelle Barber, Ken Reil, Michael Essek, Stephanie Witham, Chris Green, Joel Barnett, Carrie Hitchens, Brandon Ortega, Thomas Smale, and Josh Brown who I met all in person and had some really interesting conversations with! I should have a post about the conference coming out soon!

Many people came up and asked about this particular case study on my girlfriend’s account. It was amazing to hear over drinks that a guy implemented the exact strategy she is using to grow his account from less than 20 dollars to 800 dollars in royalties from his account the very next month! Since I know these posts are helping people, I will continue writing them so make sure you drop any questions in the comments below.

In case you missed it, here is last months case study:

100k School Debt to Financial Freedom – Merch by Amazon Update 3

If you read that case study, you may have noticed a big trend. Sales dying off and everything being slow.

I hear this constantly from the community so it is NOT just you! Sales (outside of the eclipse niche), have been pretty slow. We are seeing slower sales across the board and this month is no different.

That being said, the goal is still the same. She is working towards paying off around $100,000 worth of school debt and that is still the main purpose of this case study.

We have around 8 months left to hit this goal and I think it will for sure happen. I know I keep saying that I think it is very possible that we will hit the 100k goal within a year, but I know something that many other people do not know that have not been in program very long. I know that these stagnant sales are for the most part NORMAL. I know that print capacity goes to the big players and big trends and the main trend that was taking up all that capacity (eclipse), is now over!

Q4 has pretty much just started and I am super excited for what the future is going to bring. If you thought last years numbers were big (if you were around then), this year I actually expect them to be bigger because Merch has had an entire year to build out the facitilities and print capacity to handle it. You may remember that they completely shut off uploads for a few months last year. I expect that that will NOT be the case this time, but who knows. We have to optimize the uploads while we have them!

Last month, this account did $2,515.57 in royalties which was way down from the previous month. This month is not painting a better picture, but there a few key points I want to discuss.

What Happened In August?

In July, life pretty much happened with the amount of school and work that was happening outside of the online world. I always harp on hitting your daily uploads, but when you have other things going on and MBA is not your full time job, this can often get side tracked for other activities.

I was actually gone at another conference in California and school tests and work related things kept coming up.

After July, you can pretty much just say she was burnt out.

This happens to all of us though! I know, because it has happened to me plenty of times. All you can really do is focus on what you need to get done, and then just get back on the train and keep going.

August was the month of reboot.

A lot of you may not live with someone else that is constantly harassing you about hitting your uploads, or doing research, or really just talking about Q4 constantly. Well, we talk about merch a LOT (or at least I do), and that finally seemed to kick start the engine again.

Trending Research

Trends are a tricky one, and something I talk a lot about. Since the account in question is at the 1000 tier, this is something we wanted to make sure to hit because there are plenty of slots to capitalize on. Halloween is coming up, and we wanted to make sure that we got to market early.

The first thing that she did was hit up the Merch Hunter and look at all the Halloween designs that were already live. As you can see they are doing pretty well!

As you can see from the above screenshot, there are already a TON of designs selling and selling like hot cakes!

When you are really early on a trend, especially when it comes to a holiday, there is a great approach after using the Merch Hunter!

First, start by checking the Merch Hunter and seeing what is selling on Amazon right now. If you are early enough like we were, you should notice that some designs are selling, but the massive wave of sales has not started yet.

Second, head over to Pinterest, and do a search for “Halloween Shirts”. It should look something like this:

Right away, you are going to say to yourself “you can’t use half of those!” and that is absolutely correct.


But some of them you can!
The trick here is to go through and write down all the phrases into a sheet and then bring them back into Merch Informer. You can either put them into the Merch Hunter, or the product search. Since we are not looking at BSR ranges, I would suggest the product search.

I grabbed this screenshot a little too late but this really demonstrates this technique.

Usually we are looking for a niche that has a lot of other sellers that are selling so we know the niche has demand. With holiday niches though, if you are getting in early, you want to see little to no shirts up! The reason for this is because they are holiday niches, the goal is to get things up before they are even selling.

If you can get a shirt up with a nice phrase for that holiday before anyone else is even thinking about uploading shirts, you have a very good chance of getting a ton of sales on that shirt.

As you can see from the above screenshot, there are a few that have started to sell, but this is even more telling:

There are only TWELVE designs for that phrase that are currently selling on Merch! That right there is a massive opportunity that took about 30 seconds to dig up. Easy money for people that want to take action!

90 Day Rule

The 90 day rule is something about Merch by Amazon that I really wish was not an actual thing. I understand why they did it. It costs money to have ASINs on Amazon, and if they are not selling there is really no point in having them.

Some people think that if a design has not sold within 90 days, there is no point in putting it up again and usually just leave it.

From my experience though, I KNOW that good research went into those designs and I know there is demand for them. Usually looking at the niches with a fresh set of eyes is exactly what is needed to get that initial sale.

My girlfriend has 10 pages of this or around 150 designs that have been removed for no sales. This is a big opportunity here and something that has been happening over the past month.

The plan is to reupload them after taking another look at the niches and finding out what keywords the competition is using that IS selling shirts in those niches. Getting those 150 designs back up is going to be huge for Q4 and if she can keep up, should be ready for a tier up soon!

The Results For August

Before we get to it, here is a quick recap of the July numbers:

Last month you will see that July looks a little bit higher than was reported in the last article. This is because Amazon will pay based on when the products ship out. The extra money should be attached to the payment the month following. This month was still a down month just like the majority of people in the community are reporting, and in fact, we are down more than last month here. Keep your head up though!

I should also note that all the shirts are priced right around $16.99 except for those that have reviews and are proven sellers which have seen the price bumped up. This is the sweet spot that we have found, but I know a few others are following the same outline but have jacked all their shirts up to $19.99. This is something we are considering doing for Q4.

Here are what the current uploads are looking like. Keep in mind that we are dealing with a lot of removals for not getting a sale in 90 days.

Here is a summary of the totals for August 2017 from downloading the excel spreadsheet:

470 shirts sold with $2068.95 in royalties.

This is an absolute disappointment if we are being honest. I think it is important to remain transparent and it probably helps a lot of people that are facing the same exact thing. Q4 is just starting here, and I am happy to report that numbers are finally trending upwards from here!

The Math

Since designs can easily be created yourself (and what most people are doing when they start), we are only going to be including the royalties in the math.

    • She was doing absolutely nothing in the beginning ha! Not until some real life stuff popped up and realized she needed to make money did she start working at it and everything just exploded.

  • Thanks for writing the guide inspite of your busy schedule, Appreciate you for being transparent about the numbers. I am quite happy because I actually did better than July in August, One of the solar tee took off. But yes, negating that it was slow. I am super excited about Halloween and Q4, considering I have 250 more slots remaining how many would you advice me to put for Halloween?
    Also, You mentioned “you can’t use half of those!” below the pinterest image , I did not get what you meant there.
    Thanks again Neil!

  • Great post. About how many removals a day are you getting? Is it difficult to reach your max uploads when a few removals every day are taking away from your totals?

    • We have really not kept track of the removals on a day to day basis. They should all be put up this month though. Just a little bit of catch up needed!

  • I have just been approved to sell on Merch By Amazon. I am at the 10 tier level. I have read through all of the articles and I have a question. In the first article it stated that you use the 100k to 300k product research when you have tiered up. Is there a method that you recommend to use that is different when just getting started at the 10 tier?

    • I would either buy myself out of the lower tiers, or actually start marketing your shirts through some kind of medium (social media, in person, charity).

  • I almost never comment on a website post but maaaaaaan I went over the full case study and is great, now I know I was burning my money with Merch Informer until now that I’m gonna make Merch Informer to pay for all my past and future bills. Thanks for taking the time to share this!

  • Excellent post neil!
    Glad to hear how you were able to get your girl back into the mood of uploading shirts. I understand her burnout completely.
    thanks Neil, back to work for me!

  • Is there a reason why you’re leaving out the expense of this case-study?
    I thought you mention it in a previous post or in the comments.
    I’ve started in July and just about breaking even with the cost of designs but Q4 is coming and I know I’ll finally turn a profit soon.

    • The vast majority of people I know are doing designs themselves. Some people pay a LOT per design, while others pay almost nothing per design. Really just depends on your personal situation so we leave them out.

  • Hey Neil, It’s only September. Usually Q4 is referred to as October/November/December. Still have a month before we start to see those sales pick up?

    • This is true, but I typically start seeing sales pick up this month (if last year is anything to go off of), and keep on increasing through December.

  • Same here with the burn out, I went really hard and just needed a couple days off from not looking at the computer screen. Really hoping sales pick up too, to get out of 500. I’m doing the same average a day as I was in 100 which can also lead to getting frustrated and burned out for some. After a few days off though it feels good to keep at it again. Thanks for these updates it really motivates me as I started this at the beginning of June!

  • Thanks for the update! I’m in the 500 tier ready for Q4! I’m going to reach $5000+ a month thanks to you! Thank you for everything. All the info and MI – Amazon is big enough for everyone to win.

  • Im following this method and am I00% focused. I’m on 500 tier. I was just doing what I thought would sell made by myself and make-merch . Last weekend I started following and this week I have 40 new designs made by VA’s . It really is worth paying for good designs . Im
    averaging 4 -5 a day and hoping to get it up to 10 a day. I have sold about 240 shirts . Do they ever tier people up to 1000 before they hit 500 if they see your committed via good designs and niches ? I really want to be on 1000 tier coming into Q4.

  • The BSR isn’t shown in the Favorites list. There doesn’t seem to be a way to import it back into product search to bulk check BSR. Does it require individually clicking each shirt title and checking BSR on Amazon?

    • You can check the BSR over time when you are doing your research by clicking on the little clock button to the right. Since this gives you the historical data from the previous month, you can then use this information to determine if you should go into that niche or not. We use the favorites feature for keeping all our lists separate in order to send them to designers.

      • Thanks, Neil.
        I was referring to checking BSR from within a saved Category> I don’t see a clock icon like I do when I am in product search or march hunter. Maybe more time needs to pass and the clock will appear?
        This is what I see inside a saved category – https://imgur.com/a/urAu3

        • Yes, the BSR and price history is not in the favorites categories. We generally check that information before we add them to our favorites and then send them out to the designers right away.

  • Hello Neil,
    This is a bit off topic, but are you still planning on doing that article on how to use Amazon Associates for Merch? It would be extremely helpful. Thanks in advance

  • Hi Niel. I live in Westminster, CO. I’m on the 500 tier. I’m about to quit my part-time job and go 200% on Merch by following your methods. Case study me!

  • For Flooding a Niche
    1) Do you still look for good BSR history
    2) Are you still only looking for 100-300k BSR shirts
    3) Are you looking at shirts strictly on amazon, or are you referencing shirts off etsy or pinterest etc.
    Thanks for the great case study!

    • We will look at the BSR history for when first putting up shirts. From there, anything that is selling well we will flood the niche by looking at what else is selling on Amazon but also seeing what is selling on other platforms and then bringing them back into Merch Informer to see how big the competition is.

      • Thanks for the response! A couple of follow ups:
        1) What do you consider as “selling well”?
        2) When looking for niches, do you look at the competition or number of shirts for the niche in general, or avoid big niches like Nureses/Yoga etc.

        • I would say 1-2 a week is selling decent and I will not look at competition, because I have the slots available and will go into any niche no matter how many other players there are. This might be different if you are in a lower tier.

  • Hi Neil,
    it’s great to read this case study. Thank you for sharing!
    I have 60 designs online now and also want to grow. So I tried more about outsourcing. But I’ve just found one seller, whom I can trust (I use him for more detailed drawings, which are $20 or more).
    Whenever I try a new seller for a simple text and symbol design, I took an image from the delivered design and I will find it over google for sure! The sellers told me, they draw it, but they took stock vectors or copied it from somewhere. When I check the police from the stock page where I’ve found the image, it says, it cannot be used for commercial use, or they ask a lot of money (compared to the $ 5 – 10, I’ve paid) for commercial use. It happened to me with 8 from 8 sellers. And pretty sure, there would be stolen items, that I won’t find.
    I don’t want to loose my merch account due this and I don’t want to injure other peoples rights. But I also don’t want or can do all the designs myself (text is no problem, but even simple drawings are impossible…)
    What are your experiences? Do you have a solution for this? Maybe you can publish a blog article on this topic. Or maybe you can suggest stock image pages with free or cheep fees for commercial use.
    Thank you very much.

    • Hey Phil! This is going to happen for sure and part of the reason why I go through designers quickly in order to actually hire someone decent. If you have not already, read this article: https://merchinformer.com/use-upwork-outsource-scale-merch-business/. There is a bit of advice there to help you avoid these issues. Also make sure that you are taking a screen shot of the shirt image and right click the image in Chrome. Then click on search Google for this image. This will do a reverse Google search to make sure that the design is not already out there. Just make sure to check all the works of art and keep trying to find someone who is trustworthy. Good luck!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *